The Most Valuable Homes on Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket

David Bates / March 1, 2012-12:17 pm

Nantucket
Highest Single Family
1.  15 Top Gale Lane                 $17,815,000
2.  169 Eel Point Road              $17,176,000
3. 1 Hulbert Ave                        $14,664,000
4. 31 Hinckley Lane                  $13,919,000
5.  2 Easton St                           $13,278,000

Nantucket
Residential Multiple Buildings
1. 23 Lincoln Ave                       $31,558,000
2. 36 Shawkemo Road              $23, 806,000
3. 30 Rabbit Run Road             $23,401,000
4. 208 Polpis Road                     $21,009,000
5. 90 Pocomo Road                   $19,106,000

Edgartown, Martha’s Vineyard
Highest Single Family
1. 185 Katamam Road               $20,987,000
2. 2 Black Duck Cove                 $18,467,000
3. 35 Tower Hill Road                $18,009,000
4.  177 Katama Road                 $16,936,000
5. 315 Katama Road                   $16,613,000

Edgartown, Martha’s Vineyard
Residential Multiple Buildings
1. 83 Pohogonot Road                $25,656,000
2. 20 Jobes Neck Cove Rd          $17,881,000
3. 54 Oysta Watcha Rd              $17,345,000
4. 1 Starbuck Neck Rd                $17,075,000
5.  24 Ocean View Ave               $15,678,000

West Tisbury, Martha’s Vineyard
Highest Single Family
1. 86 Ichabod Allen Rd                $22,025,000
2. 15 Old Herring Creek rd          $20,421,000
3. 234 Middle Point Rd                $19,203,000
4. 350 Big Homers Pond Rd       $19,062,000
5. 145 Obed Daggett Rd              $14,682,000

Chilmark, Martha’s Vineyard
Highest Single Family
1. 81 Squibnocket Farm Rd          $15,293,000
2. 10 Cygnet Way                         $14,496,000
3. 67 Harlock Pond Road             $12,118,000
4. 157 A-C North Road                 $11,933,000
5.  47 King’s Highway W              $11,214,000

(Based on an analysis of assessed values in the MLS Public Records section, which was conducted in December 2011)